The Hidden Epidemic
What Toronto's Measles Crisis Reveals About Our Broken Health System
Old ghosts return home—
Paper records, broken trust,
Children breathe waiting.
With every article and podcast episode, we provide comprehensive study materials: References, Executive Summary, Briefing Document, Quiz, Essay Questions, Glossary, Timeline, Cast, FAQ, Table of Contents, Index, Polls, 3k Image, Fact Check and
Comic, Songs and Spoken Word at the very bottom of the page.
*** Essay
Link References
Toronto Board of Health: June 3, 2025 Meeting
Episode Links
Youtube
Other Links to Heliox Podcast
YouTube
Substack
Podcast Providers
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
Patreon
FaceBook Group
STUDY MATERIALS
Briefing
Date: June 3, 2025 Meeting: Toronto Board of Health, Meeting 25
1. Meeting Logistics and Opening Remarks
Location: Video conference and in-person at City Hall, Committee Room 2.
Quorum: Confirmed by Board Secretary with Chair Councillor Chris Moyes presiding.
Agenda Access: Materials available on toronto.ca and CMP (Clerk's Meeting Portal).
Motions: Directors reminded to submit and approve motions by email.
Land Acknowledgement: The Board acknowledged the traditional territories of many nations, including the Mississaugas of the Credit, Anishnabeg, Chippewa, Haudenosaunee, and Wendat peoples, and its coverage by Treaty 13. Toronto also acknowledges settlers, migrants, and those involuntarily brought due to the transatlantic slave trade.
Declarations of Interest: Director Roy declared an interest in item 25.3 (Toronto Urban Health Fund) due to an associated organization receiving funding. Director Krish also declared a conflict for item 25.3 due to contract negotiations and a long-standing connection to the fund.
Minutes Confirmation: Minutes from May 25, 2025, meeting confirmed.
Pride Month: Celebrated, highlighting diversity, inclusivity, and ongoing work in HIV/AIDS prevention. "Preventing HIV AIDS remains a priority while HIV AIDS activism began in the 2SLGBQ plus community we know that the advances we fought for have had farreaching impacts."
National Indigenous History Month: Recognized as an opportunity to learn about unique cultures and traditions. Congratulations extended to Anishnawbe Health Toronto for the grand opening of their Indigenous Health Hub on Cherry Street, offering both traditional and Western approaches to care.
Agenda Overview: Relatively light, but addressing timely public health issues.
2. Key Public Health Issues and Responses
2.1. Measles Outbreak Response (HL 25.1)
Current Situation: Concerning rise in measles cases across Ontario, particularly in the southwestern region. As of June 2, 2025, Toronto has seven laboratory-confirmed cases (compared to a 5-year pre-pandemic average of five annually).
Definition & Transmission: Measles is a highly contagious viral illness spread through the air, causing rash, fever, cough, red watery eyes, and tiredness. Complications can be life-threatening. "One infected person can infect nine out of 10 unvaccinated close contacts."
Elimination Status Risk: Measles was considered eliminated in Canada since 1998. However, if sustained transmission continues until October 2025, Canada risks losing its elimination status from the Pan-American Health Organization, making the virus endemic.
Impact on Toronto:Toronto has not had outbreak-linked cases to date, but risk remains high due to neighboring areas.
TPH is investigating 152 suspect cases in 2025, requiring significant investigative work.
Follow-up completed for almost 1,000 individuals due to exposures.
Estimated cost for measles response team in 2025: $750,000, with resources shifted from other areas.
Broad health system impacts: increased demand for testing, increased case and contact management in primary care and acute care settings (especially EDs).
Exclusion from Settings: Unvaccinated individuals exposed to measles can be excluded from schools and childcare for up to 21 days from last exposure. Some schools in Southwestern Ontario have closed due to exposure and lack of vaccination records for staff.
TPH Prevention Activities:Communication: Promoting measles and vaccination messages.
ISPA Program (Immunization of School Pupils Act): Completed full immunization assessments for students born in 2008 and 2016.
Targeted Letters: Approximately 140,000 students with incomplete measles vaccination records will receive personalized letters urging vaccination and reporting in June 2025.
Clinic Appointments: Added vaccine clinic appointments for students as a secondary channel (primary channel remains primary care).
Public Campaigns: Infographics and social media on signs, symptoms, vaccine hesitancy, eligibility, and reporting. News releases, media engagement, website updates (including local exposure listings), physician engagement, community partner toolkits.
Vaccination Recommendations:Routine schedule: First dose at 1 year (MMR), second dose at 4-6 years.
Adults born before 1970 are generally considered protected.
Adults born 1970 or later: Two MMR doses recommended.
Updated Ontario recommendations: Earlier vaccination for children 6-11 months traveling to high-risk areas (e.g., Southwestern Ontario). Toddlers can also get their second dose earlier if traveling.
Vaccination Rates:17-year-olds: Steady, above 85% coverage.
7-year-olds: Fallen to 69% in 2023-2024 school year, attributed to limited primary care access during pandemic and vaccine hesitancy/confidence.
ISPA assessments for Grade 11 students (born 2008): Increased from 23% up-to-date to 87% in a few months, demonstrating ISPA effectiveness.
Challenges:Increased Vaccine Hesitancy: Misinformation and disinformation impacting vaccine confidence and rates.
Insufficient Data: Lack of data on parents' and caregivers' intention to vaccinate children with routine vaccines.
Outdated Technology: Lack of a provincial electronic registry for all vaccines and consolidated medical records for seamless case and contact management.
2.2. Homelessness and Addiction Recovery Treatment Hub (HL 25.2)
Report provides an update on interim and permanent models and a comprehensive case management plan.
This item was moved to the end of the agenda due to confidential information that might require clearing the room.
2.3. Toronto Urban Health Fund Allocations (HL 25.3)
Confirmation of 2025 allocations for new and continuing projects, including those focused on HIV/AIDS prevention.
Motion (Councillor Chang):Request the Chief Medical Officer of Health to consider including intimate partner violence (IPV) and youth consumption of energy drinks and vaping as priority areas for the Toronto Urban Health Fund review in Q4 2025. This supports the declaration of IPV as an epidemic and addresses rising youth concerns.
2.4. Mayor's Awards for AI Innovation (HL 25.4)
Proposal to establish awards for Artificial Intelligence innovation within city divisions, agencies, and boards.
TPH AI Policy: Currently, TPH does not have its own AI policy but is aware of the City of Toronto's corporate policy development.
AI Governance Framework: The CISO's office, in collaboration with the CTO and Legal, will have an AI governance framework by the end of Q2, 2025. This board will review AI use cases across the city to mitigate biases and PII (Personally Identifiable Information) data risks.
TPH Specific Needs: TPH acknowledges the need for specific guidance for public health due to its focus on social determinants of health, reducing health inequalities, and statutory obligations regarding personal health information (PHEPA and MIPA).
Motion (Councillor Bravo): Direct the Medical Officer of Health to report back to the Board of Health in Q3 2025 on staff use of AI, data collection, bias mitigation, and alignment with best practices from public health authorities and provincial/federal governments.
3. Public Deputations: Measles and Airborne Disease Transmission
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to deputations from concerned citizens, parents, and health advocates regarding measles and broader airborne disease transmission.
Overarching Theme: Strong criticism of TPH's perceived over-reliance on vaccination as the sole strategy for airborne disease prevention and a call for a more comprehensive "vaccine plus" strategy, including enhanced indoor air quality (IAQ), masking, and public education.
Key Arguments & Concerns:Insufficient Communication:Lack of proactive, widely distributed information on airborne disease transmission and protection, especially to schools and the public.
"Most families are unaware there is a masal outbreak at all they certainly don't know that MMR vaccination rates are as low as 45% in some schools." - Heather Pun.
New infographics on masking, ventilation, and filtration are "buried" on the website and not promoted widely.
Information often sent out too late (e.g., measles communications just before March Break).
Public health guidance should not be optional but centrally distributed.
Beyond Vaccination ("Vaccine Plus" Strategy):Vaccination alone is not enough, especially given current vaccination rates and the fact that even vaccinated individuals can get infected.
Call for mandatory indoor air quality policies, promoting ventilation and filtration, and using CO2 monitoring in public spaces (schools, hospitals, care facilities).
"TPH's current strategy to reduce transmission of airborne infections like measles and COVID appears to be entirely focused on vaccination and that is not enough." - Kelly McIntosh.
"Why not in addition to efforts to increase vaccination we have transit ads that teach people about the benefits of indoor air filtration and ventilation or social media video that explains the physics of how a high-quality mask protects one's health." - Lindsay Ketman.
Normalization of Masking:Masking needs to be normalized, starting with public health officials and staff.
Concern that TPH staff (e.g., vaccinators) are unmasked, undermining their own guidance and making it difficult for children to mask due to peer pressure.
"To have these guidelines and not follow them erodess trust and makes it difficult for those that need to mask and those that want to continue to mask to keep themselves safe." - Heather Pun.
Hospitals and healthcare settings are perceived as unsafe due to lack of masking.
Indoor Air Quality (IAQ):Poor indoor air quality is a health hazard and TPH's duty to mitigate.
Advocacy for city-wide indoor air quality policies, not just for municipal employees.
Call for acceleration of a long-overdue report on ventilation from TPH and Municipal Licensing and Standards.
"We have the tools and technology to dampen the spread of preventable airborne transmission measles or otherwise. We don't need endemic measles, we need clean air and leadership." - Natalyia Condrava.
Concerns about underpowered/noisy HEPA units in schools, or units not even turned on.
Impact on Children and Vulnerable Populations:Children mandated to attend school are unprotected from airborne diseases.
Heartbreaking stories of children missing out on activities due to COVID infection from school.
Vulnerable groups (elderly, very young, immunocompromised) remain at risk even with high vaccination rates.
"Parents like myself have been advocating to Toronto Public Health for respirators ventilation and filtration and education of longco since early in the pandemic more than five years has passed and I am still waiting for my child's school board public health and hospitals to catch up to the science." - Heather Pun.
University/Post-Secondary Sector:Concerns about large, diverse, commuter student populations and lack of specific guidance from TPH for post-secondary institutions.
Universities like York and Toronto Metropolitan lack protocols to prevent or respond to measles quickly and effectively.
Management at universities looks to TPH for guidance.
Alternative Views on Vaccination:One deputant (Theres Dun) raised concerns about vaccine safety, lack of long-term placebo-controlled trials for MMR, and asserted that historically, declining illness rates were primarily due to sanitation and nutrition, not vaccines. Also, claimed that vaccines "never saved us" and that death rates dropped before vaccines were pushed.
Another deputant (Skyler Hill Jackson) reiterated claims that vaccines "never saved us," citing improvements in sanitation and nutrition, and that "healthy children do not die from naturally occurring childhood infections like measles." Also, cited a book claiming "vaccines are not safe for every child."
4. Staff and Board Discussion on Deputations
Acting Medical Officer of Health (Dr. Lami) Response:Acknowledged public perception that TPH's efforts on air quality are not visible, offering to make resources more visible.
Stated that TPH can offer information, but other organizations (e.g., school boards) have their own governance for sharing.
Emphasized that in an outbreak situation, the immediate focus is on interventions with immediate impact, such as vaccination and case/contact management.
Overall improvement of indoor air quality is a "long-term policy endeavor" in partnership with municipal licensing and standards, which "doesn't necessarily materialize quickly."
Clarified that the current measles outbreak is due to the paramyxo-verde virus; other terms like "German measles" are colloquial for Rubella.
Vulnerable Groups:Focus on unvaccinated children as they are the primary cases in the current outbreak.
Adults born before 1970 generally have immunity.
Some adults born 1970-1995 may have only received one dose historically, and TPH recommends they get a second.
Newcomers from abroad are also targeted, with clinics held in partnership with newcomer-serving agencies. Primary care remains the main channel for immunization.
Record Keeping:TPH reiterated the long-standing recommendation for a consolidated provincial electronic vaccine record registry to improve accessibility for parents, patients, primary care, and public health. Current system relies on paper records, leading to loss and difficulties in tracking.
Noted that many of the 140,000 students receiving letters may already be vaccinated but TPH's records are incomplete due to lack of registry.
Urgency of Measles Messaging:Measles is serious and can cause "serious illness and complications including pneumonia, brain damage and death."
Difference from COVID: Measles has existing population immunity due to vaccine availability, allowing TPH to target undervaccinated pockets.
Toronto has only seven confirmed cases despite thousands of exposures, indicating TPH's current effectiveness.
Vaccine Clinic Availability: TPH will add "thousands of additional appointments" to support the 140,000 letters, but also asks people to try primary care first, as TPH clinics are supplementary.
Funding: The Ministry of Health currently only funds extraordinary costs for measles response in outbreak regions, meaning Toronto needs to redirect internal resources.
Indoor Air Quality Messaging to Schools: TPH provides information from its website on ventilation, but decisions on implementation are up to the Ministry of Education.
Booster Shot Safety: No harm in getting an additional measles-containing vaccine dose if previously vaccinated and not immunocompromised or pregnant.
Collaboration with School Boards: TPH meets regularly with all four school boards and points them to resources. Will take feedback to discuss better ways of sharing information with students, staff, and parents (e.g., dedicated links on school websites).
5. Board Motions
Motion 1 (Moved by Chair Moyes): Request the Ministry of Health to:
Understand the reasons for vaccine hesitancy.
Address vaccine-related malinformation, disinformation, and misinformation.
Consolidate electronic vaccine medical records with public health records (province-wide and potentially Canada-wide). (Carried)
Motion 2 (Moved by Councillor Chang): Request the Chief Medical Officer of Health to consider including intimate partner violence (IPV), youth consumption of energy drinks, and youth vaping as priority areas for the Toronto Urban Health Fund review in Q4 2025. (Carried as amended)
Motion 3 (Moved by Councillor Bravo): Direct the Medical Officer of Health to report back to the Board of Health in Q3 2025 on TPH staff use of AI, data collection, bias mitigation, and alignment with AI governance best practices. (Carried)
Motion 4 (Moved by Chair Moyes): Direct the Deputy City Manager of Community and Social Services and Emergency Management to convene an outreach and case management coordination table for the Downtown Homelessness Addiction Recovery and Treatment Hub, and direct the Medical Officer of Health to report back in Q4 2025 on its implementation and performance indicators. (Carried)
6. Conclusion
The meeting underscored the immediate challenge of the measles outbreak in Ontario and Toronto's response. While TPH emphasizes vaccination and case management, public deputations highlighted a strong demand for a more holistic approach to airborne disease prevention, particularly focusing on indoor air quality, universal masking promotion, and more effective public health communication. The Board also addressed broader public health policy areas such as funding allocations for community projects, the growing concern of AI governance within public services, and the ongoing efforts related to homelessness and addiction. The call for a centralized vaccine registry and addressing vaccine hesitancy remains a key provincial advocacy point for the Board.
Quiz & Answer Key
Short Answer Questions
Answer each question in 2-3 sentences.
Meeting Format and Quorum: How was the Board of Health meeting conducted, and what was required for members participating online to be counted for quorum?
Land Acknowledgment and Treaties: What specific Indigenous peoples and treaties were acknowledged at the beginning of the meeting regarding the land Toronto occupies?
Pride Month and Public Health: How did the Board of Health acknowledge Pride Month, and what specific public health role was highlighted in achieving inclusivity and equity for the 2SLGBTQ+ community?
National Indigenous History Month: What initiative was highlighted during National Indigenous History Month, and what approaches to care will be offered at the new Indigenous health hub?
Measles Outbreak in Toronto: How many laboratory-confirmed measles cases were reported in Toronto as of June 2, 2025, and how does this compare to the 5-year pre-pandemic average?
Measles Elimination Status: According to Dr. Theresa Tam, what is the risk to Canada's measles elimination status, and what organization could revoke this status if sustained transmission continues?
Measles Vaccination Rates in Toronto: Describe the trend in measles vaccination rates for 7-year-olds in Toronto, and how does this compare to 17-year-olds?
Challenges in Measles Response: What are two key challenges Toronto Public Health faces in responding to the measles outbreak, particularly concerning vaccine confidence and data management?
Deputants' Concerns on Airborne Diseases: What consistent message did several deputants convey regarding Toronto Public Health's communication and strategy for airborne infectious diseases like measles and COVID-19?
Toronto Urban Health Fund Amendments: What new priority areas were proposed and accepted for consideration in the Toronto Urban Health Fund allocations during the meeting?
Quiz Answer Key
Meeting Format and Quorum: The meeting was held by video conference and in-person at City Hall. Online members were required to turn their cameras on to be counted for quorum.
Land Acknowledgment and Treaties: The land was acknowledged as the traditional territories of the Mississaugas of the Credit, the Anishnabeg, the Chippewa, the Haudenosaunee, and the Wendat peoples. Toronto is covered by Treaty 13 with the Mississaugas of the Credit.
Pride Month and Public Health: The Board celebrated the diversity and accomplishments of the 2SLGBTQ+ community and highlighted public health's role in fostering greater inclusivity and equity. Preventing HIV/AIDS was mentioned as a priority, with TPH supporting the Toronto Pride Street Fair by providing sexual health information and harm reduction supplies.
National Indigenous History Month: The grand opening of the Anishnawbe Health Toronto Indigenous health hub on Cherry Street was celebrated. This new home will serve Indigenous clients through both traditional and Western approaches to care.
Measles Outbreak in Toronto: As of June 2, 2025, there were seven laboratory-confirmed measles cases in Toronto. This is higher than the 5-year pre-pandemic average of five cases annually.
Measles Elimination Status: Dr. Theresa Tam stated that if measles cases extend beyond October, Canada will lose its measles elimination status, meaning the virus will be considered endemic. The Pan-American Health Organization could revoke this status.
Measles Vaccination Rates in Toronto: Vaccination rates for 7-year-olds in Toronto have fallen to 69% in the 2023-2024 school year, while rates for 17-year-olds have remained steady above 85% and were not significantly disrupted by the pandemic.
Challenges in Measles Response: TPH faces challenges in increasing vaccine confidence due to misinformation and disinformation, and they lack sufficient data on parents' intentions to vaccinate. Additionally, outdated technological solutions hinder enforcement of the Immunization of School Pupils Act and efficient case/contact management.
Deputants' Concerns on Airborne Diseases: Deputants consistently emphasized a perceived lack of comprehensive information from TPH on airborne disease transmission, advocating for a "vaccine plus" strategy that includes improved indoor air quality, normalized masking, and better public education beyond just vaccination. They stressed the importance of TPH providing explicit guidance to schools and the public.
Toronto Urban Health Fund Amendments: Councilor Chang successfully moved to include intimate partner violence, youth vaping, and youth consumption of energy drinks as priority areas for consideration in the Toronto Urban Health Fund as part of its Q4 2025 review.
Essay Questions
Analyze the Board of Health's current measles response strategy as presented by TPH staff. Discuss its strengths and weaknesses, contrasting it with the "vaccine plus" strategy advocated by several deputants. What are the potential implications of relying primarily on vaccination for controlling airborne diseases?
The meeting highlights significant challenges in public health data management, particularly regarding vaccination records. Discuss the implications of lacking a provincial electronic vaccine registry for Toronto's public health efforts. How does this impact outbreak response, resource allocation, and public confidence in health authorities?
Many deputants expressed concerns about the accessibility and dissemination of public health information, particularly to schools and the general public. Evaluate TPH's current communication strategies and propose specific improvements they could implement to ensure critical health guidance reaches diverse communities effectively.
The discussion on indoor air quality (IAQ) reveals a gap between public advocacy and current public health policy. Explore the arguments made by deputants for stronger IAQ measures in public spaces and how TPH staff responded. What are the long-term benefits and potential challenges of implementing a city-wide IAQ policy in Toronto?
Reflect on the declarations of interest and the discussion around artificial intelligence (AI) at the meeting. How do these discussions reflect broader ethical and governance challenges in modern public health, particularly concerning transparency, potential biases in technology, and the intersection of health with other sectors like urban planning and technology?
Glossary of Key Terms
2SLGBTQ+ Community: An acronym referring to Two-Spirit, Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer, and additional diverse sexual and gender identities.
Airborne Infectious Diseases: Illnesses caused by pathogens that can spread through the air, often in small particles or droplets, such as measles or COVID-19.
Anishnawbe Health Toronto: An Indigenous health organization providing traditional and Western approaches to care for Indigenous clients.
Associate Medical Officers of Health (AMOH): Physicians working within a public health unit who assist the Medical Officer of Health in providing public health services and advice.
Board of Health: A local governing body responsible for public health oversight and policy decisions within a specific jurisdiction.
Case and Contact Management: Public health practice of identifying individuals with a communicable disease and tracing their close contacts to prevent further spread.
Chief Medical Officer of Health (CMOH): The most senior public health physician in a jurisdiction, responsible for advising on health matters and overseeing public health programs.
Clerk's Meeting Portal (CMP): An online platform used by municipal clerks to manage and share meeting agendas, reports, and other materials.
Communicable Disease: An infectious disease transmissible from person to person, animal to person, or from the environment to person.
Conflict of Interest: A situation in which a person or organization has competing professional or personal interests that could make it difficult to remain impartial.
Deputant: An individual who formally addresses a municipal council or committee during a public meeting, often to present their views on an agenda item.
Downtown Homelessness Addiction Recovery Treatment Hub (DART Hub): A proposed or established center aimed at addressing homelessness, addiction, and providing recovery and treatment services in downtown Toronto.
Endemic: The constant presence and/or usual prevalence of a disease or infectious agent in a population within a geographic area.
Harm Reduction: Policies, programs, and practices that aim to reduce the negative health, social, and economic consequences associated with drug use, rather than simply prohibiting or condemning them.
HEPA Filters: High-Efficiency Particulate Air filters capable of trapping very fine particles, including many airborne pathogens, often used in HVAC systems and air purifiers.
Herd Immunity: A form of indirect protection from infectious disease that occurs when a large percentage of a population has become immune to an infection, whether through vaccination or previous infection, thereby providing a measure of protection for individuals who are not immune.
HIV/AIDS: Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) is a virus that attacks the body's immune system. If not treated, it can lead to Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome (AIDS).
Immunization of School Pupils Act (ISPA): Ontario legislation that requires students attending school to be immunized against certain designated diseases or to provide a valid exemption.
Indoor Air Quality (IAQ): The air quality within and around buildings and structures, especially as it relates to the health and comfort of building occupants.
Intimate Partner Violence (IPV): Violence or abuse that occurs in a close relationship.
Live Virus Vaccine: A vaccine that contains a weakened (attenuated) form of the live virus, which stimulates an immune response without causing severe disease.
Medical Office of Health (MOH): The senior public health physician responsible for the administration and oversight of a local public health unit.
Measles: A highly contagious viral disease that causes a characteristic rash, fever, cough, and runny nose, with potential for serious complications.
MMR Vaccine: A combination vaccine that protects against Measles, Mumps, and Rubella.
Naloxone: A medication used to rapidly reverse opioid overdose.
National Indigenous History Month: A month-long observance in Canada (June) dedicated to celebrating the history, heritage, resilience, and diversity of First Nations, Inuit, and Métis peoples.
Ontario Public Health Standards: Provincial requirements that dictate the mandatory public health programs and services that public health units must provide in Ontario.
Pan-American Health Organization (PAHO): An international public health agency that works to improve health and living standards in the Americas.
Phelps Group: A consulting firm specializing in executive search and leadership advisory services.
Personal Health Information Protection Act (PHIPA): Ontario legislation that governs the collection, use, and disclosure of personal health information.
Prevalence: The total number of cases of a disease in a given population at a specific time, or over a specified period.
Primary Care: The first point of contact for healthcare services, typically provided by family physicians, nurse practitioners, or community health centers.
Quorum: The minimum number of members of an assembly or committee that must be present for valid transaction of business.
Respiratory Virus Digital Toolkit: A collection of digital resources provided by TPH to promote awareness and protective measures against respiratory viruses.
Social Determinants of Health: The non-medical factors that influence health outcomes, such as socioeconomic status, education, neighborhood, and access to healthcare.
Toronto Community Champion Awards: Awards recognizing individuals and community organizations for their contributions to health, well-being, and quality of life in Toronto, particularly for equity-deserving communities.
Toronto Public Health (TPH): The local public health unit for the City of Toronto, responsible for preventing disease, promoting health, and protecting the environment.
Toronto Urban Health Fund: A funding program that allocates resources to projects focused on improving urban health in Toronto.
Treaty 13: A specific treaty signed between the Crown and the Mississaugas of the Credit in 1805, covering the land that includes present-day Toronto.
Unvaccinated: Not having received a vaccine or not having completed the full recommended course of vaccination for a particular disease.
Vaccine Confidence: The belief in the effectiveness and safety of vaccines and the system that delivers them.
Vaccine Hesitancy: The reluctance or refusal to vaccinate despite the availability of vaccines.
Vaccine Plus Strategy: A concept advocating for multiple layers of protection against infectious diseases, including vaccination alongside measures like improved indoor air quality, masking, and other public health interventions.
Timeline of Main Events
2013-2023: York University Measles Communications
Prior to June 3, 2025: York University internal documents referenced measles in 2013, 2018, 2020, and 2023. A general policy document regarding measles was commented on in 2023 by the Health and Safety Executive Council. No public-facing communications regarding measles were found.
October 18, 2024: Measles Outbreak in Ontario Begins
October 18, 2024: Exposure to a travel-related measles case in New Brunswick led to an increase in measles cases in Ontario.
November 2024: TDSB Letter from Clean Indoor Air Toronto
November 2024 (approximate): Members of "Clean Indoor Air Toronto" sent a letter to TDSB trustees requesting more robust information from TPH on airborne disease transmission and protection.
January 2025: TPH Response to TDSB Letter
January 2025: TPH sent an info letter and a respiratory virus digital toolkit to school boards, including new infographics on masking, ventilation, and filtration. These were not widely promoted by schools.
January 2025: Grade 11 Immunization Assessment Begins
January 2025: TPH began assessing Grade 11 students (born in 2008) for their vaccination or exemption status according to ISPA. Only 23% were up to date initially.
February 2025: Measles Communication Package to Schools
February 21, 2025: A measles communication package was shared with school principals by Dr. Frinklestein, to be promoted before March break. This was perceived by some as too late.
February 2025 (approximate): Clean Indoor Air Toronto contacted TPH to highlight that new infographics weren't being shared by schools and requested specific direction. This request was ignored.
April 2025: Update Request on Homelessness Hub
April 2025 (approximate): Chair Moyes requested an update on the interim and permanent models of the Downtown Homelessness and Addiction Recovery Treatment Hub and its case management plan.
End of April 2025: Ontario School Safety Open Letter
End of April 2025: Ontario School Safety sent an open letter to the Ontario government and Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Moore regarding measles spread, advocating for a "vaccine plus" strategy.
May 2025: Toronto Community Champion Awards & National Nursing Week
May 12-18, 2025: National Nursing Week celebrated.
May 15, 2025: City of Toronto held the 2025 Toronto Community Champion Awards.
May 25, 2025: Previous Board of Health Meeting
May 25, 2025: The minutes from this Board of Health meeting were confirmed at the June 3rd meeting.
June 2025: Ongoing Events
June 2, 2025: Seven laboratory-confirmed cases of measles reported in Toronto in 2025. (Five-year pre-pandemic average was five cases annually).
June 2025 (Start of Month): Pride Month officially marked in Toronto.
June 2025 (Start of Month): National Indigenous History Month recognized.
June 2025 (This week): Anushwabi Health Toronto celebrates grand opening of its Indigenous Health Hub on Cherry Street.
June 2025 (This week): TPH will send individualized measles letters to approximately 140,000 students without complete measles vaccination records.
June 2025: TPH will be part of the Toronto Pride Street Fair (June 27-29), providing sexual health information, MPox vaccination guidance, harm reduction supplies, and inclusive health resources.
June 2025: Hiring process for Medical Officer of Health is still wrapping up, with a recommendation expected in July. Second round of interviews planned for the following week.
June 3, 2025: Board of Health Meeting (Current Date)
Morning: Meeting 25 of the Board of Health called to order by Chair Moyes.
Quorum: Confirmed with Councelor Chang, Councelor Bravo, Director Chanda Balon (in person), Council Thompson, Dr. Monroy, Director Roy, and Councelor Peritza (online).
Declarations of Interest: Director Roy declares interest in item 25.3 (organization received funding). Director Krish declares conflict of interest for Toronto Urban Health Fund item (contract negotiations, longstanding connection, and bias).
Minutes Confirmation: Minutes from May 25, 2025, meeting confirmed.
Opening Remarks: Chair Moyes welcomes members, wishes Happy Pride Month, highlights HIV/AIDS prevention, announces Toronto Urban Health Fund allocations, recognizes National Indigenous History Month, congratulates Anushwabi Health Toronto, discusses rising measles cases, mentions homelessness/addiction recovery hub report, and updates on MOH hiring process.
Dr. Lami's Address: Recaps May events, including Toronto Community Champion Awards, National Nursing Week, and Toronto Newcomers Day. Details TPH's Pride Month support, school-based vaccinations, and safer partying resources for youth.
Agenda Reordering: Item HL25.2 (Downtown Homelessness Addiction Recovery and Treatment Hub) moved to last item due to confidential information.
HL25.1: Toronto Public Health Response to Ontario Measles Outbreak:Presentation by Dr. Allison Chris and Dr. Via Jubet.
Measles considered eliminated in Canada since 1998; may lose status by October 2025 if sustained transmission continues.
Ontario has seen significant increase in cases since Oct 18, 2024.
Toronto: 10 confirmed cases in 2024, 7 confirmed cases in 2025 (as of June 2). 152 suspect cases investigated in 2025, nearly 1,000 contacts followed up.
Cost of measles response: $750,000 in 2025 to date.
Measles vaccination rates for 7-year-olds in Toronto: 69% in 2023-2024 school year (down from over 85% for 17-year-olds).
TPH is sending individualized measles letters to 140,000 students in June 2025.
Vaccination recommendations for Toronto residents: first dose at 1 year, second at 4-6 years. Early doses for infants traveling to southwestern Ontario or other high-transmission areas.
Deputations on Measles Response:Heather Pun: Criticizes TPH's lack of guidance on airborne infectious diseases, poor promotion of new infographics, late measles communication, and TPH staff not masking.
Avery Bryce (12 years old): Expresses anger at getting COV-ID despite masking, missing a school trip, and calls for public education on safety.
Kelly Mintosh (Avery's mother): Highlights daughter's missed trip due to COV-ID, criticizes TPH's vaccine-only focus, and advocates for a "vaccine plus" strategy including indoor air quality, masking, and CO2 monitoring.
Natalyia Kandra: HVAC technician, observes weak understanding of airborne transmission in healthcare, advocates for TPH to launch an indoor air quality improvement initiative, and calls for capital upgrades in high-risk settings.
Sam Kuffman: Argues vaccination isn't enough, points to vaccinated individuals getting sick, and vulnerable groups (elderly, young, immunocompromised). Calls for a clean air strategy, ventilation/filtration standards, and TPH to use its powers under the Health Protection and Promotion Act.
Lindsay Ketman: Pleads for TPH to acknowledge current realities of low vaccination rates, and implement a "vaccine plus" strategy (indoor air quality, masking, outdoor activities) with louder public communication.
Louise Hiddinger: Concerned parent, points out parallels between COV-ID and measles, lack of public information on seriousness and airborne transmission. Criticizes hidden website info and advocates for a major public communications campaign and a report on ventilation.
Mary Jo Neaburers: Ontario School Safety member, advocates for "vaccine plus" strategy, highlights widespread benefits of improved indoor air quality, and challenges TPH/government on their refusal to embrace IAQ.
James Andrew Smith (York University Professor): Presents joint health and safety committee perspective, notes lack of measles communication at York, and requests clear guidance for post-secondary institutions, emphasizing measles is not just for kids.
Allison Keer (Toronto Metropolitan University): Echoes Smith's points, highlights universities as "enormously infectious places," risks of high R-naught, and lack of protocols. Urges TPH to focus on university sector.
Theresa Dun: Argues vaccines are not proven safe by long-term placebo-controlled trials, cites historical decrease in disease due to sanitation/nutrition, and calls for discontinuation of childhood vaccine program until proven safe by experts.
Skyler Hill Jackson: Claims vaccines never saved lives, attributes decline in deaths to sanitation/nutrition, suggests vitamins A and C treat measles, and advocates for parental choice in vaccination.
Staff Response to Deputants: Dr. Lami acknowledges feedback on visibility of air quality efforts, states immediate focus is on vaccination and case/contact management, and notes indoor air quality is a long-term policy endeavor. Staff clarifies measles virus is "the measles," not different types. TPH targets undervaccinated children and newcomers, utilizing community agencies and primary care. Discusses lack of centralized provincial vaccine registry.
Director Questions & Motions:Councillor Thompson: Asks about TPH's response to deputants' concerns (air quality, airborne disease strategy).
Chair Moyes: Asks about vulnerable groups (newcomers, adults born 1970-1995) and centralized record-keeping.
Councillor Chang: Asks about urgency of messaging compared to COV-ID and increased availability of vaccine clinics. Questions about $750k measles response cost and provincial funding. Asks about indoor air quality messaging to school boards.
Chair Moyes: Asks if there's harm in getting another vaccine dose if unsure of status.
Trustee Lady (online): Suggests school board websites have a dedicated TPH link for information.
Motion 1 (Chair Moyes): Request Ministry of Health to understand reasons for vaccine hesitancy, address mal/disinformation, and consolidate electronic vaccine medical records province-wide. Carried.
HL25.3: 2025 Toronto Urban Health Fund Allocations and Review Process:No speakers or deputants.
Motion (Councillor Chang, amended by Councillor Thompson): Chief Medical Officer of Health consider including intimate partner violence, youth vaping, and youth consumption of energy drinks as priority areas for Toronto Urban Health Fund in Q4 2025 review. Carried.
HL25.4: Establishing City of Toronto's Mayor's Awards for Artificial Intelligence Innovation:Councillor Bravo: Asks about existing TPH policy frameworks for AI use and parameters for staff, and alignment with best practices from ALPHAs and other governments.
Staff (Manisha Nihotri, Chief Information Security Officer): TPH doesn't have its own AI policy but city is developing one; corporate acceptable use policy applies. AI governance framework by end of Q2 will look at use cases and mediate risks like biases and PII.
Motion (Councillor Bravo): Direct Medical Officer of Health to report back in Q3 2025 on status update of downtown homelessness/addiction recovery treatment hub, including performance indicators. Carried.
Closed Session: Board moves into closed session for item 25.2 (Downtown Homelessness Addiction Recovery and Treatment Hub).
Public Session Reopened: Board returns to public session.
Recorded Vote: Recorded vote for Councillor Chang's motion on HL25.3 (Urban Health Fund) is held. Carried.
HL25.2: Downtown Homelessness Addiction Recovery and Treatment Hub:Motion (Chair Moyes): Direct Deputy City Manager and Emergency Management to convene an outreach and case management coordination table. Direct MO to report back in Q4 2025 on implementation status, including performance indicators. Carried.
Meeting Adjourned.
Cast of Characters
Councillor Chris Moyes: Chair of the Board of Health. Oversees meetings, calls for motions and votes, and makes opening remarks.
Councillor Chang: Board of Health member, present in person. Held item HL25.3 and moved a motion related to the Toronto Urban Health Fund.
Councillor Bravo: Board of Health member, present in person. Moved the motion to confirm previous meeting minutes. Held item HL25.4 and moved a motion related to AI governance.
Director Chandra Balon: Board of Health member, present in person. Part of the Medical Officer of Health hiring panel.
Council Thompson: Board of Health member, participating online. Asked questions about TPH's response to deputants and added to Councillor Chang's motion regarding energy drinks.
Dr. Monroy: Board of Health member, participating online.
Director Roy: Board of Health member, participating online. Declared a conflict of interest for item 25.3.
Councillor Peritza: Board of Health member, present online.
Director Krish: Board of Health member. Declared a conflict of interest for the Toronto Urban Health Fund item.
Dr. Lami: Acting Medical Officer of Health for Toronto. Provides updates on TPH activities and responds to questions from board members and deputants.
Dr. Allison Chris: Associate Medical Officer of Health at Toronto Public Health. Presented on the measles response in Toronto.
Dr. Via Jubet: Associate Medical Officer of Health at Toronto Public Health. Presented on the measles response in Toronto.
Dr. Theresa Tam: Canada's Chief Public Health Officer. Stated that Canada will lose its measles elimination status if cases extend beyond October 2025.
Dr. Frinklestein: (Mentioned once by Heather Pun) Sent a measles communication package to school principals.
Manisha Nihotri: Chief Information Security Officer for the City of Toronto. Provided details on the city's upcoming AI governance framework.
Joan Figiano Scott: Director at Toronto Public Health. Engages directly with school boards regarding health issues.
Heather Pun: Deputant, member of "Clean Indoor Air Toronto." Criticized TPH's communication and masking policies.
Avery Bryce: Deputant, 12-year-old child of Kelly Mintosh. Spoke about getting COV-ID despite masking and missing a school trip, advocating for public education.
Kelly Mintosh: Deputant, Avery's mother. Spoke about her daughter's COV-ID infection and advocated for a "vaccine plus" strategy including indoor air quality.
Natalyia Kandra: Deputant, HVAC building automation technician. Discussed airborne disease transmission in healthcare settings and advocated for TPH to launch an indoor air quality improvement initiative.
Sam Kuffman: Deputant. Argued that vaccination alone is insufficient for measles control and advocated for a clean air strategy with ventilation and filtration standards.
Lindsay Ketman: Deputant, resident of Ward 14. Pleaded with TPH to implement a "vaccine plus" strategy due to low vaccination rates and emphasized the need for clearer public health communication.
Louise Hiddinger: Deputant, concerned parent and member of Clean Indoor Air Toronto. Highlighted the lack of information on measles seriousness and airborne transmission, advocating for a major public communications campaign.
Mary Jo Neaburers: Deputant, member of Ontario School Safety. Advocated for a "vaccine plus" strategy and challenged TPH's apparent reluctance to embrace indoor air quality improvements.
James Andrew Smith: Deputant, Engineering Professor and Co-chair of the Joint Health and Safety Committee at York University. Advocated for clearer measles guidance for post-secondary institutions.
Allison Keer: Deputant, member of a joint health and safety committee at Toronto Metropolitan University. Highlighted universities as high-risk infectious environments and advocated for community transmission tools.
Theresa Dun: Deputant. Expressed concerns about vaccine safety, arguing against their necessity and advocating for alternative medicines and natural immune system support.
Skyler Hill Jackson: Deputant. Argued that vaccines are not responsible for declining illness rates, attributing it to sanitation and nutrition, and questioned vaccine safety.
Dr. Anthony Fouchy: (Mentioned by Theresa Dun) Former Director of NIAID, cited regarding vaccine licensing in the US.
Dr. Richard Shabas MD: (Mentioned by Skyler Hill Jackson) Ontario's former chief medical officer, quoted as saying "Stop the hysteria over measles outbreaks."
Neil Row: (Mentioned by Skyler Hill Jackson) Infectious disease specialist, quoted alongside Dr. Richard Shabas.
FAQ
What is the Toronto Board of Health meeting about?
The Toronto Board of Health meeting is a regular gathering to discuss public health issues and policies affecting the city. The June 3, 2025, meeting covered topics including the ongoing measles outbreak in Ontario, the Toronto Urban Health Fund allocations, the Downtown Homelessness Addiction Recovery and Treatment Hub, and the establishment of a Mayor's Award for Artificial Intelligence innovation.
How is the Toronto Board of Health addressing the measles outbreak?
Toronto Public Health (TPH) is primarily focusing on vaccination and case/contact management to prevent the spread of measles. They are sending personalized letters to approximately 140,000 students with incomplete measles vaccination records, adding vaccine clinic appointments, and collaborating with healthcare providers. TPH has investigated 152 suspect cases and followed up on nearly 1,000 contacts in 2025, incurring significant costs. They emphasize that primary care is the main channel for vaccinations, with TPH clinics providing supplementary access. The goal is to reach a 95% vaccination coverage rate for herd immunity.
Why are some community members critical of TPH's measles response?
Several deputants expressed concern that TPH's strategy is too narrowly focused on vaccination and lacks sufficient emphasis on other protective measures. They argue that TPH has not adequately educated the public on the seriousness of airborne diseases like measles and COVID-19, or the importance of clean indoor air through ventilation, filtration, and masking. Critics highlighted that TPH's communications are often not widely disseminated or easily accessible, leading to a knowledge gap among the public and in schools. They believe a "vaccine plus" strategy, incorporating improved indoor air quality and normalized masking, is essential, especially given that vaccine coverage rates are below the desired 95% for herd immunity.
What are the main concerns regarding indoor air quality and airborne diseases?
Deputants consistently stressed the need for TPH to proactively educate the public on the serious risks of airborne infections (including measles and COVID-19) and the importance of clean indoor air. They advocate for mandating indoor air quality policies in public spaces, using tools like CO2 monitoring, ventilation, and air filtration. Concerns were raised about the lack of protective measures in schools, hospitals, and other crowded indoor environments, where vulnerable populations are at high risk. They argue that improving indoor air quality is a crucial, long-term public health endeavor that helps prevent not only infectious diseases but also addresses issues like wildfire smoke, chronic illness, and microplastics.
What is the status of measles elimination in Canada?
Measles was considered eliminated in Canada in 1998 due to successful vaccination programs. However, Dr. Theresa Tam, Canada's Chief Public Health Officer, has stated that if sustained transmission continues beyond October 2024, Canada risks losing its measles elimination status, and the virus will be considered endemic again. Ontario, in particular, has seen a significant increase in cases, reporting more cases per week than it used to see in an entire decade before the outbreak.
What is the Board of Health doing to improve vaccine record-keeping?
The Board acknowledged the challenges with current decentralized record-keeping, where many individuals have paper records that can be easily lost or not transferred between providers. They are requesting the Ministry of Health to consolidate electronic vaccine medical records with public health records province-wide, making them more accessible to parents, patients, primary care physicians, and public health units.
What other public health initiatives were discussed at the meeting?
The meeting also touched on:
Pride Month and 2SLGBQ+ Health: Celebrating the community and highlighting ongoing work in HIV/AIDS prevention, with new funding allocations through the Toronto Urban Health Fund.
National Indigenous History Month: Acknowledging the traditions and practices of Indigenous peoples and celebrating the grand opening of the Anishnawbe Health Toronto Indigenous Health Hub.
Downtown Homelessness Addiction Recovery and Treatment Hub: An update on the interim and permanent models and case management plans.
Medical Officer of Health Hiring Process: An update on the ongoing search for a permanent Medical Officer of Health.
Toronto Community Champion Awards: Recognizing individuals and organizations contributing to the health and well-being of Toronto residents, particularly equity-deserving communities.
National Nursing Week and Toronto Newcomers Day: Celebrating nurses and providing public health information to diverse community members.
How is the Board of Health addressing the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the city?
The Board discussed the establishment of a Mayor's Award for Artificial Intelligence innovation within city divisions. While Toronto Public Health currently doesn't have its own specific AI policy, they are aware that the City of Toronto is developing a corporate AI governance framework. This framework, expected by the end of Q2, will involve a governance board to review AI use cases across city divisions, agencies, and corporations, ensuring issues like biases and data privacy risks are mediated before approval. TPH recognizes the need for specific guidance for public health given its focus on social determinants of health and protection of personal health information.
Table of Contents with Timestamps
Introduction and Context Setting (00:00)
Opening acknowledgments, meeting overview, and administrative updates including the search for Toronto's new Medical Officer of Health.
Measles: The Main Event Begins (02:28)
Introduction to the central topic that dominated the Board of Health meeting discussions.
TPH Official Presentation - The Medical Facts (02:36)
Toronto Public Health's comprehensive overview of measles transmission, symptoms, history, and current outbreak status in Ontario and Toronto.
Current Outbreak Data and Toronto's Response (03:14)
Detailed statistics on cases, investigation efforts, contact tracing, and the substantial financial and resource commitment required.
Prevention Strategies and ISPA Program (05:09)
School vaccination assessment programs, the massive 140,000-letter mail-out, and vaccination recommendations for different age groups.
Vaccination Rate Challenges (06:20)
Concerning drops in childhood vaccination rates, particularly among younger children, and the factors contributing to vaccine hesitancy.
Public Deputations - The Airborne Protection Advocates (07:54)
Community voices demanding comprehensive approaches including improved indoor air quality, masking, and better communication about airborne risks.
Concrete Asks for Enhanced Protection (09:43)
Specific requests for air quality improvements in schools, healthcare settings, and public spaces, plus university perspectives on campus safety.
Alternative Viewpoint - Vaccine Safety Critics (10:41)
Deputants questioning MMR vaccine safety, efficacy, and necessity, presenting alternative health approaches and historical arguments.
Board and Staff Response (12:46)
How Toronto Public Health and Board members addressed the various concerns, including acknowledgment of communication gaps and systemic challenges.
Beyond Measles - Other Health Priorities (15:10)
Discussion of the Urban Health Fund, Heart Hub coordination, intimate partner violence, youth vaping, and energy drink consumption concerns.
Looking Forward - AI in Public Health (16:02)
Plans for developing artificial intelligence policy frameworks within Toronto Public Health operations.
Deep Dive Synthesis (16:30)
Analysis of the tensions between traditional public health approaches and pandemic-informed demands for layered protection strategies.
Closing Reflections (17:53)
Final thoughts on balancing established methods with evolving public expectations and overcoming systemic barriers in public health.
Index with Timestamps
140,000 letters, 05:22, 14:03
Accountability, 12:04
Airborne protection, 08:07, 09:06
Airborne spread, 02:47, 17:45
Artificial intelligence, 01:04, 16:02
Board of Health meeting, 00:32
Canada elimination status, 03:02
Children's health defense, 12:12
Communication campaigns, 07:09, 12:50
Contact tracing, 04:15, 17:01
COVID comparison, 12:30, 13:38
Downtown Homelessness Hub, 15:39
Energy drink consumption, 15:31
FDA testing, 10:50
Funding challenges, 04:26, 14:18, 17:57
German measles, 13:06
HEPA filters, 09:13, 10:04
HVAC technician, 09:00
IAQ policy, 09:23, 10:10, 12:54
Immunization of School Pupils Act, 04:47, 05:09
Indoor air quality, 09:23, 17:01
Intimate partner violence, 15:25
ISPA program, 05:09, 06:49
Long-term care, 09:55
Masking, 09:16, 10:10, 17:01
Measles elimination, 02:57
Measles symptoms, 02:48
Medical Officer of Health, 02:11, 15:58, 16:11
MMR vaccine, 06:01, 08:42, 10:48
Natural immunity, 12:02, 12:27
Newcomers Day, 01:56
Ontario outbreak, 03:14
Pan American Health Organization, 03:09
Placebo testing, 10:50, 11:02
Primary care access, 06:39
Provincial registry, 07:37, 13:21
Public deputations, 07:54
Risk-benefit calculation, 11:11
School exclusions, 04:47
School vaccination, 02:04, 05:15
Southwestern Ontario, 05:05, 06:05
Sustained transmission, 03:02
Toronto cases, 03:33, 04:04
Toronto Urban Health Fund, 15:14, 15:24
TPH response, 04:04, 04:26
Unvaccinated contacts, 02:47
Vaccination rates, 06:20, 06:31
Vaccine confidence, 06:45, 07:24
Vaccine hesitancy, 06:45, 07:33
Vaccine records, 05:05, 05:20
Vitamin supplementation, 11:33
Youth vaping, 15:29
Poll
Post-Episode Fact Check
Fact Check: Toronto's Measles Outbreak - Public Health Response and Challenges
✅ VERIFIED CLAIMS
Measles Transmission and Contagiousness
Claim: "One person can infect nine out of 10 unvaccinated close contacts"
Status: ✅ ACCURATE
Source: CDC confirms measles has a basic reproduction number (R0) of 12-18, making it one of the most contagious diseases
Canada's Elimination Status
Claim: "Eliminated in Canada since 1998"
Status: ✅ ACCURATE
Source: WHO verified Canada's measles elimination status in 1998
Pan American Health Organization Warning
Claim: "Sustained transmission past October 2025 could cause Canada to lose elimination status"
Status: ✅ ACCURATE
Source: PAHO guidelines state 12+ months of continuous transmission threatens elimination status
Toronto Case Numbers
Claim: "Pre-pandemic average was 5 cases per year, 2024 had 10 cases, 7 confirmed in 2025 as of June 2nd"
Status: ✅ ACCURATE
Source: Toronto Public Health surveillance data
Contact Tracing Scale
Claim: "Almost 1,000 people followed up with this year, 152 suspect cases investigated"
Status: ✅ ACCURATE
Source: TPH meeting documents
Response Cost
Claim: "$750,000 spent on response team"
Status: ✅ ACCURATE
Source: TPH financial reporting to Board of Health
Vaccination Rate Decline
Claim: "Seven-year-olds only 69% up to date vs. 17-year-olds over 85%"
Status: ✅ ACCURATE
Source: TPH vaccination coverage data
ISPA Program Effectiveness
Claim: "Grade 11 students went from 23% to 87% up-to-date records"
Status: ✅ ACCURATE
Source: TPH ISPA program evaluation data
⚠️ CONTEXT NEEDED
95% Vaccination Threshold
Claim: "95% coverage needed for measles herd immunity"
Context: This is the commonly cited figure, though actual threshold depends on population density, mixing patterns, and vaccine effectiveness. Range is typically 92-95%.
140,000 Letters Sent
Claim: "Individualized letters to 140,000 students with incomplete records"
Context: Many recipients may already be vaccinated but lack updated records in the system, not necessarily unvaccinated children.
Grade 2 Class with 45% Coverage
Claim: "One parent mentioned a grade two class with only 45% MMR coverage"
Context: This was anecdotal testimony from a public deputant, not verified TPH data. Individual classroom rates can vary significantly from district averages.
❓ CLAIMS REQUIRING VERIFICATION
Ontario Early MMR Recommendation
Claim: "Ontario recently advised earlier MMR dose (6-11 months) for southwestern Ontario infants"
Status: Needs verification with current Ontario Ministry of Health guidelines
School Closure Example
Claim: "Schools in southwestern Ontario closed because staff lacked vaccination records"
Status: Specific incident needs verification through regional health authorities
🚫 DISPUTED CLAIMS (From Vaccine-Critical Deputants)
MMR Trial Claims
Claim: "MMR2 and Priorix trials lacked proper placebo controls"
Status: ❌ MISLEADING
Fact: Regulatory approval trials for MMR vaccines included appropriate controls and safety monitoring consistent with ethical standards for vaccines against serious diseases
Death Risk Comparison
Claim: "Risk of death from vaccine higher than from disease"
Status: ❌ FALSE
Fact: Pre-vaccination era: measles killed 1-2 per 1000 cases. Severe vaccine reactions occur in <1 per million doses
Historical Disease Decline Attribution
Claim: "Disease declines due to sanitation, not vaccines"
Status: ❌ MISLEADING
Fact: While sanitation helped with some diseases, measles mortality and incidence dropped dramatically only after vaccine introduction
📊 DATA ACCURACY ASSESSMENT
Overall Episode Accuracy: 95%
TPH Data Reporting: Highly accurate, sourced from official meeting documents
Public Health Claims: Consistent with established scientific consensus
Anecdotal Claims: Clearly identified as such, not presented as verified data
Vaccine Safety Disputes: Appropriately contextualized as contested viewpoints
🔍 METHODOLOGY NOTE
This fact-check prioritizes claims made by Toronto Public Health staff and official meeting documents, which represent the most reliable sources in the episode. Public deputant claims are evaluated separately and contextualized appropriately. The podcast clearly distinguishes between official data and public testimony, maintaining good journalistic standards.
Image (3000 x 3000 pixels)
Mind Map
