The China Story We're Not Telling

Keyu Jin's Fresh Take on the World's Most Misunderstood Economy

Feb 10, 2025

Everyone thinks they understand China's economy. They're probably wrong.

While Western pundits obsess over ghost cities and debt crises, they're missing the forest for the trees. That's where Keyu Jin comes in – and she's got a perspective that might just flip everything you think you know about China's economic miracle on its head.

Jin isn't your typical academic economist. Sure, she's got the Harvard PhD and LSE professorship, but she's also got something rarer: the ability to see China's economy from both the inside and outside. As the daughter of the AIIB founding president and someone who's advised everyone from the World Bank to Goldman Sachs, she brings a unique lens to this conversation.

And what she sees might surprise you.

Take what she calls the "mayor economy." While Western economists debate the merits of top-down versus bottom-up approaches, Jin points out that China's actually running a fascinating hybrid: a tournament-style system where local officials compete based on economic growth. It's like "The Apprentice" meets central planning, and it's been spectacularly effective at driving development.

But here's where it gets really interesting.

Jin argues that we can't understand China's economy without understanding Chinese society. This isn't just about GDP numbers or trade balances. It's about fundamental values that shape economic behavior in ways most Western analysts completely miss.

Consider this bombshell: 95% of Chinese people prioritize security over freedom, compared to just 27% of Americans. That's not just a cultural curiosity – it's the key to understanding why China's economic model works the way it does.

The implications are huge.

When Western commentators cry foul about state intervention in the economy, they're missing the point. The Chinese people, Jin argues, have a fundamentally different relationship with their government. It's more paternalistic, more focused on collective outcomes than individual liberty. And guess what? For a lot of Chinese people, that's exactly what they want.

But don't mistake this for some kind of apologetics for authoritarian control. Jin's analysis is far more nuanced than that.

She points out how this system has enabled China to make spectacular leaps in technology and innovation. Remember when "Made in China" meant cheap knockoffs? Those days are long gone. Today, four out of the five most downloaded apps in the U.S. are Chinese. That's not an accident – it's the result of a strategic partnership between state and private sector that Western free-market purists can barely comprehend.

The "six wallets" phenomenon is another perfect example of how cultural values shape economic reality. In China, young people often buy expensive homes because they can tap into support from both parents and grandparents. It's a system that would make most Western financial advisors' heads explode, but it works within China's cultural context.

But here's the kicker: none of this means China's economy is invincible or that their model is perfect.

Jin is refreshingly candid about the challenges. Local government debt? Yeah, it's a problem. The need for painful structural reforms? Absolutely. The tension between centralized control and innovation? That's real too.

What sets Jin's analysis apart is her refusal to fall into the trap of either cheerleading or doom-mongering. Instead, she offers something far more valuable: a framework for understanding how China's economy actually works, warts and all.

This matters more than ever as China attempts to shift from an investment-heavy growth model to one driven by innovation and consumption. It's a transition that will reshape the global economy, whether we're ready or not.

Take the RMB's role in international finance. Jin doesn't buy into simplistic narratives about the dollar's imminent demise or China's unstoppable rise. Instead, she points out the very real obstacles – from market depth to currency convertibility – while acknowledging China's strategic moves to increase the RMB's global role.

Here's the bottom line: China's economy isn't just a bigger version of Western capitalism, nor is it the communist boogeyman of Cold War nightmares. It's something new, something different, and something we need to understand on its own terms.

The world is becoming more multipolar, more complex, and more interconnected. Old models and assumptions are breaking down. Understanding China's economy isn't just an academic exercise – it's crucial for anyone who wants to grasp where the global economy is heading.

Keyu Jin's insights offer us a rare chance to move beyond the usual talking points and really understand what makes China's economy tick. It's not always comfortable, especially for those wedded to Western economic orthodoxy, but it's essential.

The question isn't whether China's economic model is "right" or "wrong" – it's whether we're willing to understand it for what it actually is, rather than what we assume it to be.

References:

Keyu Jin
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keyu_Jin

Prof. Keyu Jin: What Americans GOT WRONG About China's Economy

Understanding a Global Superpower: Another Look at the Chinese Economy with Keyu Jin

The New China Playbook: Beyond Socialism and Capitalism

What the World Can Learn From China’s Innovation Playbook | Keyu Jin | TED

HelioxPodcast: Where Evidence Meets Empathy

Podcast:

Heliox: Where Evidence Meets Empathy

Substack:

Episode:

The New China Playbook by Keyu Jin (S3 E5 )

Select your podcast provider

Heliox: Where Evidence Meets Empathy on Youtube

Table of Content

Table of Contents with timestamps:

00:00-01:34 | Introduction and Background

- Introduction to Keyu Jin and her unique perspective

- Overview of her academic and professional background

- Discussion of her global influence and expertise

01:35-02:38 | Understanding Jin's Journey

- Details about her early life in Beijing

- Education at Horace Mann and Harvard

- Development of her cross-cultural perspective

02:38-04:03 | The Mayor Economy Concept

- Explanation of decentralized dynamism

- Discussion of local competition and economic growth

- Analysis of the solar panel industry example

04:03-05:02 | Challenges and Trade-offs

- Environmental concerns

- Regional inequalities

- Sustainability issues in real estate

05:02-06:30 | Cultural Values and Economic Behavior

- World Value Survey data analysis

- Security vs. freedom priorities

- State-people relationship discussion

06:30-09:03 | Innovation and Technology

- Evolution from manufacturing to tech leadership

- Discussion of Chinese apps' global success

- Government's role in technological advancement

09:03-12:12 | Generational Shifts and Economic Changes

- Six wallets phenomenon

- Changing consumer behavior

- Impact of younger generations

12:12-15:10 | Challenges and Transitions

- Discussion of economic slowdown

- Analysis of ghost cities

- Transition to consumption-based economy

15:10-18:19 | Global Financial Ambitions

- RMB's role in global markets

- Digital currency initiatives

- International financial system analysis

18:19-20:27 | Conclusion and Future Implications

- Summary of key insights

- Discussion of China's future role

- Final thoughts on global economic leadership

Table of Contents with timestamps: